Museum Curators
A curator secretly classifies objects. Guests test rival theories by offering imaginary exhibits that separate one explanation from another.

Set the scene
Privately choose a rule based on normal use, for example “objects designed to contain liquid.” Start with kettle and bottle admitted, comb and cushion declined.
How to play
- On their turn guests nominate one object and predict its column. The curator records it. Guests may discuss hypotheses but do not announce a final theory yet.
- After six tests ask for two competing explanations. Someone might suggest “usually in the kitchen.” Try a soap dispenser, then a wooden spoon, to separate the theories.
- The group gets one formal theory and predicts two fresh objects selected by the curator. Win by matching both predictions and the underlying rule within twelve tests.
Host’s note
Declare a borderline example “withdrawn” before recording a verdict. A leaky bucket can derail a round about intended use.
Try a variation
For children, classify real objects by one visible quality and let them physically move each exhibit to its column.
More in this collection
MysterySignal Circle
A returning observer tries to locate the person initiating gestures while the circle discreetly copies each change.
MysteryAlibi Calendar
Players check a fictional schedule for a single impossible appointment. Good investigators ask about travel time as well as clock time.
MysterySealed Destination
A courier must identify a destination on a grid using directions from people who each hold only one piece of the map.