Six-Question Switch
Two objects trade places in a small display. The returning detective gets six yes-or-no questions before naming the pair.

Set the scene
Lay out a key, pen, cup, eraser, coin and spool in six marked places. Let the detective study the display for twenty seconds, then turn away.
How to play
- The group swaps exactly two objects. Cover the display before the detective turns back; the puzzle is solved through questions, not by spotting the swap.
- Allow six questions answered yes or no, such as “Did exactly one moved item start in places one to three?” Track answers where everyone can see them.
- The detective names two original positions. Uncover and check the pair. If wrong, let the group suggest the question that would have distinguished the remaining options.
Host’s note
Keep an untouched copy of the original order on a host's slip. It settles disagreements about what a player meant by “started near the cup.”
Try a variation
Play with numbered animal pictures instead of objects and allow a player to point at groups of cards while asking questions.
More in this collection
MysteryTwo Witness Sketch
Two witnesses receive different views of a drawing. A sketch artist has to decide which details belong together.
MysteryThe Silent Majority
A lone dissenter holds a near-neighbor word. Listen for differences in use and context before the table commits to a vote.
MysteryParcel Chain
A parcel has four handover stamps but the labels have come unstuck. Track its handlers by matching changes to the package.