Archive After Hours
A mixed-up closing log contains enough information to order four errands. Nobody may pass a clue slip across the table.

Set the scene
Label tasks Stamp, Photograph, Wrap and Shelve. Privately divide these clues: “Stamp immediately before Photograph,” “Wrap after Photograph,” “Shelve after Wrap,” and “Stamp was not last.” With three players one person holds two clues. With more than four, give each clue to partners and let spare players challenge proposed orders.
How to play
- Give the team two minutes to exchange clues aloud. Appoint a clerk to move task cards on the shared strip only when asked.
- Ask a skeptic to propose a different order. For every suggested swap, a player must say which clue it breaks or agree that it works.
- Lock the answer when every player agrees. Read the unique sequence Stamp, Photograph, Wrap, Shelve. Finish by identifying the redundant clue about the stamp.
Host’s note
If stuck, draw four empty boxes, then ask which two tasks have to travel as a pair whenever they move.
Try a variation
Challenge teams to replace the redundant clue with one that would still prove the sequence if another clue went missing.
More in this collection
MysteryCounterfeit Caption
Blend an invented photo caption among eyewitness accounts, then question the writers about what could actually be seen.
MysteryMuseum Curators
A curator secretly classifies objects. Guests test rival theories by offering imaginary exhibits that separate one explanation from another.
MysterySignal Circle
A returning observer tries to locate the person initiating gestures while the circle discreetly copies each change.