Counterfeit Caption
Blend an invented photo caption among eyewitness accounts, then question the writers about what could actually be seen.

Set the scene
Choose a photo such as a market stall with a striped awning. Give one shufflable role slip marked “invent” and all others marked “observe.”
How to play
- Show the photo for twenty seconds and hide it. Observers write one true visible detail. The inventor changes exactly one visible detail, such as stripes into dots.
- Read signed captions and invite one question per writer. Permit “I can't remember” as an answer. Ask voters to identify a detail they could check in the image.
- Point to the suspect caption at the same time. Show the photo to check; each accurate voter earns one point, and the inventor earns one per mistaken voter. Rotate after one photo.
Host’s note
If an observer remembers incorrectly, label it a memory slip and show both disputed details. Cancel that round's points rather than guessing intent.
Try a variation
For remote play, send the role privately, share the picture on screen and have everyone send captions to the host before discussion.
More in this collection
MysteryMuseum Curators
A curator secretly classifies objects. Guests test rival theories by offering imaginary exhibits that separate one explanation from another.
MysterySignal Circle
A returning observer tries to locate the person initiating gestures while the circle discreetly copies each change.
MysteryAlibi Calendar
Players check a fictional schedule for a single impossible appointment. Good investigators ask about travel time as well as clock time.